Suburban street with houses and palm trees. Photo: FilterGrade via Unsplash, Unsplash License (free to use).
Quick Answer
Citizens Property Insurance, Florida’s state-backed insurer of last resort, has fallen to about 270,000 policies, down roughly 81% from its October 2023 peak of 1.41 million. Citizens cut 2026 homeowners rates by an average 8.8%, 21 carriers have entered Florida since the 2022-23 reforms, and average premiums fell in 51 of 67 counties in the first half of 2026.
How Small Has Citizens Become?
Citizens Property Insurance Corporation was created to cover Florida homeowners who cannot find coverage in the private market. During the state’s insurance crisis, it grew into Florida’s largest property insurer. Its rapid shrinkage since then is one of the clearest measures of how Florida’s property insurance market has changed.
Citizens Policy Count Over Time
| Date | Policies | Source |
|---|---|---|
| October 2023 (peak) | About 1.41 million | Citizens Property Insurance |
| October 31, 2025 | 482,570 | WPTV |
| November 2025 | More than 900,000 policies shed since the peak | News4Jax |
| December 19, 2025 | 396,387 | WUSF |
| March 2026 | About 336,000 | Citizens Property Insurance |
| August 31, 2026 | 266,231 | Beinsure, citing Florida regulators |
| September 2026 | About 270,000 | Insurance Business |
Sources as listed.
From about 1.41 million policies at its peak to about 270,000 in September 2026, Citizens shrank by roughly 1.14 million policies, or about 81%. Between March and September 2026 alone, the count fell by about 66,000 policies, roughly 20%.
News4Jax reported in November 2025 that Citizens was no longer Florida’s largest property insurer for the first time since before the COVID-19 pandemic, and that about 199,000 policies were transferred to private insurers in October 2025 alone. WUSF reported in December 2025 that the policy count was the lowest since at least 2012, according to the Citizens website.
How Much Risk Has Left Citizens?
The policy count understates how much exposure has moved. Beinsure, reporting on Florida regulators’ September 2026 rate announcements, said Citizens’ total insured value was about $553 billion in 2023 and was expected to fall to about $85 billion in 2026, a decline of roughly 85%. Citizens’ residential market share was about 2%, and its staff had fallen from about 1,390 full-time employees three years earlier to 882 in 2026.
| Measure | Peak period | 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Policies | About 1.41 million (October 2023) | 266,231 (August 31, 2026) |
| Total insured value | About $553 billion (2023) | About $85 billion (expected) |
| Full-time employees | About 1,390 | 882 |
| Residential market share | Largest insurer in Florida | About 2% |
Sources: Beinsure; Citizens Property Insurance; News4Jax.
Dividing insured value by policies gives a rough sense of the book’s makeup. At the peak, about $553 billion across about 1.41 million policies averaged roughly $392,000 of insured value per policy. In 2026, about $85 billion across about 266,000 policies works out to roughly $320,000. Those are Florida Authority Network™ calculations from the reported figures.
How Are Policies Leaving Citizens?
Most of the decline comes from depopulation, also called takeouts, in which private insurers offer to assume Citizens policies. Citizens said in December 2025 that its 2025 depopulation program transferred more than 546,000 policies to private insurers. WPTV reported at the end of October 2025 that about 42% of the homeowners moved that year went to private insurers in Florida, and that Citizens planned to keep issuing takeout offers in 2026. Insurance Business reported in September 2026 that Citizens had sent 45,000 nonrenewal notices to homeowners statewide as part of its depopulation program, giving recipients about a year to find replacement coverage.
Under Florida law, as described by Insurance Business, Citizens customers must accept a private offer if it is priced within 20% of their Citizens premium. Because Citizens rates have historically been lower than private market premiums, moving to a private carrier may raise costs for some homeowners.
Are Florida Insurance Rates Coming Down?
The rate data point in the right direction for homeowners.
Citizens 2026 Rate Changes
| Policy type | Average change |
|---|---|
| Homeowners multiperil | -8.8% |
| Homeowners wind-only | -5.5% |
| Minimum change for all Personal Lines policyholders | At least -2% |
Source: Citizens Property Insurance, March 4, 2026.
Those cuts followed Citizens’ December 2025 recommendation, which the Board of Governors described as a statewide average personal lines decrease of 2.6%, the first average rate decrease since 2015, with three of five policyholders in line for an average cut of 11.5%, or $359. The final approved homeowners cuts were deeper.
The Office of Insurance Regulation approved the cuts, which took effect July 1, 2026, for new policyholders and apply at renewal for existing policies. Citizens President and CEO Tim Cerio credited litigation-reduction reforms and said private insurers now offer more options.
What About Private Market Premiums?
Insurance Business, citing Florida Office of Insurance Regulation data from April 2026, reported a statewide average homeowner premium of $3,815 including wind coverage. Citing the Insurance Information Institute, it reported that average premiums fell in 51 of Florida’s 67 counties in the first half of 2026, about 76% of counties.
For Florida homeowners, the direction has turned. Rates are falling at the state insurer and in most counties.
What Are Private Insurers Doing to Rates?
The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation approved another round of homeowner rate cuts in September 2026, according to Beinsure.
| Insurer | Average rate cut | Policies affected |
|---|---|---|
| One Alliance North America Insurance Company | 10.4% | 17,148 |
| Vyrd Insurance Company | 10.4% | 26,751 |
| Safe Harbor Insurance Company | 4.1% | 10,501 |
| Unique Insurance Company | 3.2% | 8,266 |
| Total | About 7% average | More than 62,000 |
Source: Beinsure, citing the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, September 23, 2026.
The broader filing data show how far the market has moved. Since January 2024, 48 insurers have filed for rate decreases and 53 have requested no change, according to Beinsure. The 30-day average requested homeowner rate change was a 4.8% decrease, compared with a 5.2% average increase five years earlier. In July 2022, the average approved homeowner increase was 15.33%.
Beinsure also reported that Kin Insurance cut average homeowner rates by more than 20% in Broward, Miami-Dade and Palm Beach counties in September 2026, and that HO-3 litigation rates in those counties fell from 24.1% in 2022 to 2% in 2025, according to Office of Insurance Regulation data cited by Kin. Florida Insurance Commissioner Michael Yaworsky said he expected larger reductions later in 2026 and into 2027.
Why Has the Private Market Returned?
Insurance Business identified several factors behind the recovery:
- New capacity. Twenty-one carriers have entered the Florida market since the 2022 and 2023 reforms, according to Insurance Business. Citizens’ own counts have risen over time, from 17 new insurers cited in December 2025 to 20 in a June 2026 report cited by Beinsure.
- Profitability. Florida domestic property insurers posted a combined ratio of about 77% in 2025, according to Guy Carpenter. A combined ratio below 100% means an insurer paid out less in claims and expenses than it collected in premiums.
- A quiet hurricane season. The Guy Carpenter figure was helped by a quiet 2025 hurricane season, according to the report.
- Legal reforms. Citizens’ leadership credited litigation-reduction reforms for the healthier market.
A 77% combined ratio means Florida domestic insurers kept roughly 23 cents of every premium dollar after claims and expenses in 2025. That profitability is what attracts new carriers and allows existing ones to take policies out of Citizens.
How Is Citizens Managing Its Own Risk?
As its policy count shrinks, Citizens needs less reinsurance. Reinsurance News reported in March 2026 that Citizens aimed to buy about $2.98 billion of private risk transfer for 2026, including about $1.53 billion carried over from 2025 and about $1.45 billion of new coverage. The program’s budgeted cost was about $350 million.
According to the report, a 1-in-100-year event would expose about 26% of Citizens’ surplus under that program. Spread across about 270,000 policies, a $350 million risk transfer budget works out to roughly $1,300 per policy, a Florida Authority Network™ calculation that shows how expensive catastrophe protection remains even for a much smaller insurer. Lower exposure means less risk of assessments, the special charges that Citizens can levy on Florida policyholders if it cannot pay claims after a major storm.
Citizens Snapshot, 2026
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Policies (September 2026) | About 270,000 |
| Peak policies (October 2023) | About 1.41 million |
| 2026 homeowners multiperil rate change | -8.8% |
| 2026 wind-only rate change | -5.5% |
| 2026 risk transfer target | About $2.98 billion |
| Budgeted risk transfer cost | About $350 million |
| Surplus exposed in a 1-in-100-year event | About 26% |
| Nonrenewal notices sent (as of September 2026) | 45,000 |
Sources: Citizens Property Insurance; Reinsurance News; Insurance Business.
What Should Policyholders Do?
Citizens President and CEO Tim Cerio urged homeowners to compare premiums rather than renew automatically, even when their insurer leaves rates unchanged, according to Beinsure. WPTV, citing the Insurance Information Institute, reported that homeowners now have more options than before and can shop for coverage rather than simply accepting a takeout offer. With dozens of insurers filing for rate decreases, comparison shopping is more likely to produce savings than it was during the crisis years.
What Does This Mean for Florida Businesses?
The insurance shift matters well beyond homeowners.
- Real estate. Lower and more available insurance improves affordability for buyers, which supports home sales and the agents, lenders and title companies that depend on them.
- Insurance agencies. A private market with 21 new carriers creates more options, and more competition, for independent agents placing coverage.
- Taxpayer risk. A smaller Citizens reduces the risk that a major hurricane triggers assessments on policyholders across the state.
- Household budgets. Falling premiums in most counties free up money for spending in the broader economy.
- Storm risk remains. A quiet 2025 season helped insurer results, so the market’s health still depends heavily on weather.
- Less litigation. HO-3 litigation rates in Broward, Miami-Dade and Palm Beach counties fell from 24.1% in 2022 to 2% in 2025, according to OIR data cited by Kin Insurance.
Brian’s Take
When I evaluated insurers as an investment analyst, the combined ratio was the first number I checked. Florida’s domestic property insurers posting a combined ratio of about 77% in 2025 is a remarkable turnaround. That is the kind of profitability that draws capital, and the 21 new carriers entering the market since the reforms are proof that capital has followed.
The shrinkage at Citizens is the result. Going from about 1.41 million policies to about 270,000 in three years takes enormous risk off the state’s books. For every Florida property owner, including businesses, that reduces the danger of statewide assessments after a major storm.
My caution is simple. Part of that 77% came from a quiet hurricane season, and Florida will not have quiet seasons forever. The real test of this market will come after the next major hurricane. Until then, the numbers are moving in the right direction for Florida homeowners and businesses.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many policies does Citizens Insurance have?
About 270,000 as of September 2026, according to Insurance Business, down from a peak of about 1.41 million in October 2023.
Did Citizens lower its rates for 2026?
Yes. Homeowners multiperil rates fell an average of 8.8% and wind-only rates fell 5.5%, effective July 1, 2026, for new policies and at renewal for existing ones.
What is the average homeowners insurance premium in Florida?
The statewide average was $3,815 including wind, based on April 2026 Office of Insurance Regulation data cited by Insurance Business.
How many new insurers have entered Florida?
Twenty-one carriers have entered the Florida market since the 2022 and 2023 reforms, according to Insurance Business.
How much insured value does Citizens still carry?
Beinsure reported that Citizens’ total insured value was about $553 billion in 2023 and was expected to fall to about $85 billion in 2026.
Are private Florida insurers cutting rates?
Yes. In September 2026, regulators approved average cuts of about 7% for more than 62,000 policies at four insurers, and 48 insurers have filed for decreases since January 2024, according to Beinsure.
Is Citizens still Florida’s largest insurer?
No. News4Jax reported in November 2025 that Citizens was no longer Florida’s largest property insurer, and Beinsure put its residential market share at about 2% in 2026.
What is the Citizens 20% rule?
Citizens customers must accept a private market offer priced within 20% of their Citizens premium, as described by Insurance Business.
Sources and Further Reading
- Citizens 2026 Multiperil Rates to Drop Statewide, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
- Citizens Cuts Policy Count to 270,000 Amid Nonrenewal Push, Insurance Business
- Citizens Rates Fall as Policy Count Decline Drives Lower Reinsurance Demand, Reinsurance News
- Citizens Property Insurance Now Has Fewer Than 400,000 Policies, WUSF
- Florida Approves Home Insurance Rate Cuts, Beinsure
- Citizens Recommends Rate Cuts for Most Policyholders, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
- Citizens Insurance Moves 350,000 Florida Homeowners to Private Insurers, WPTV
- Citizens Insurance No Longer Florida’s Largest Property Insurer After Major Policy Drop, News4Jax